Cardano token holders rejected Toto Finance's request for 22 million ADA, about $5 million, to buy physical copper. Stake voting against the plan outweighed stake in favor by more than 140 to 1, and the defeat leaves more room under the treasury's spending cap.
Cardano token holders voted down a proposal to spend about $5 million from the blockchain's treasury on physical copper. The ballot closed Sunday, and stake voting against exceeded stake in favor by more than 140 to 1.
Toto Finance, which issues blockchain tokens backed by commodities, had asked for 22 million ADA. The treasury is funded by a portion of network fees and newly issued tokens, and holders vote on how it is spent.
What the proposal would have done
According to the proposal, about two-thirds of the funds would have bought COMEX-grade copper stored near New Orleans. The metal would have been tokenized at one token per pound. Toto planned to hold it for 18 to 24 months and then sell, with proceeds returned to the treasury by month 36.
Copper would also have needed to rise about 49% for the treasury to win back its ADA if ADA's dollar price stayed flat. Toto stood to collect up to about 3.36 million ADA, roughly 15% of the request, through fees. Founder Monty Metzger told CoinDesk at the time: "Toto takes no profit from this proposal."
Delegated voters and the committee say no
Delegated representatives cast just over 20 million ADA for the plan and 2.86 billion ADA against it. Another 131 million ADA voted no-confidence. Treasury withdrawals need yes votes from 67% of the active voting stake. Toto got less than 1% of the stake that picked a side.
The seven-member constitutional committee gave no support either. Three members voted no and four did not vote.
Treasury cap keeps room
Holders capped withdrawals at 500 million ADA through about July 2027, and 457.4 million ADA of that was committed as of Oct. 16. Toto's request alone would have used more than half of what was left.
Toto Finance had not answered CoinDesk's questions, including whether it plans to resubmit the proposal, by publication time.
Sources: CoinDesk, Crypto Briefing
Trading involves risk.